Wi-Fi Technology Forum

PCMCIA card differences

Wireless Forum thread: http://www.wi-fitechnology.com/viewthread7.html


garyj - 19/1/03 at 18:43

Not only am I new to all this Wi-Fi stuff, I also know very little about PCs. (My main/desktop computer runs RISC OS4) So please bear with me.

I've been trying to price up PCMCIA wireless cards for a laptop. (802.11 11Mb) but there seems to be a huge difference in price. I've seen some at £40 and some Xircom ones at about £120.

Why so much difference in price?


hantsbrush - 20/1/03 at 21:24

I don't want to seem to be telling someone the obvious but it looks like you've got price differentials between a complete card including the PCMCIA part - usually the two together cost between £80 - £100 and just the carrier bit or the actual PCI card that allows the PCMCIA to be inserted.

It does make them somewhat expensive. The cheapest way is to use a USB card and they also have some flexibility in siting them for best performance. If you're only going to
use the card ina notebook then a £40 - £60 card should do the trick. After all they all have to subscribe to the standard - I've got a mixed setup of usb and PCI/PCMCIA cards and all works (fairly) well.
Hope this helps.


Danny56 - 30/1/03 at 00:10

I am new to the Forum i think this is a good idea i think Wi-Fi will be the next great communication tool i would like any one opinion on the Sprintpcs Air Cards.


nkendrick - 1/2/03 at 21:55

It's like anything commercial--you pays your money you makes your choice. More expensive cards should be of better quality but you're possibly also paying more for the brand name.
I have two Sitecom PC Card Wi-fi cards picked up at PC World (Portsmouth) for £29.99 each and they work fine.

NK


Law - 10/2/03 at 04:14

Go get a Agere Silver WI Fi card. The won't steer you wrong and are XP native. It took 7 secs for it to detect, load drivers and jump on my network.



-L


matthead - 15/2/03 at 06:16

WI-FI Cards are pretty much like anything else we go to buy at the shop. The more you pay the better the quality/support you get for your money. In principle they all do the same job.

I use Belkin PCMCIA card and a Sitecom Usb adapter. I like Belkin as they provide FREE tech support 24 hours a day by telephone.


Law - 16/2/03 at 05:39

Another thing to think about is the chipset on the card too. Certain networking tools only work with certain chip sets.



-L


Danny56 - 21/2/03 at 02:03

Sprintpcs just came to the market with a wireless pc connection called CF2031 it was reviewed in pc magazine the card also allows the user to make calls over the interent the spped is suppose to reach 144 mbs.


Laptopper - 11/9/03 at 21:30

I struggled with the Orinoco Gold Classic with winXP and gave up. I may have a bad card since they get such rave reviews. I bought an el-cheapo Blitzz brand pcmcia card and it installed and connected in seconds. The distance exc. is great but no antenna option. Blitzz $38


DCI - 6/2/04 at 00:51

PCMCIA cards differ greatly in quality. The good ones specify the transmit power and the receive sensitivity. A very good card will have a transmit power of +23 dBm and a receive sensitivity of -94 dBm. An average card will have a TX power of +15 dBm and a RX sensitivity of -80 dBm. This is an average of 10 times the sensitivity and power.

Ralph www.dci.ca


This thread come from : Wi-Fi Forums and Message Boards
http://www.wi-fitechnology.com/

Url of this website:
http://www.wi-fitechnology.com/viewthread7.html